Настройки cookie / Manage cookies
Мы используем файлы cookie для наилучшей работы сайта.
Пожалуйста, ознакомьтесь с нашей Политикой конфиденциальности.
We use cookies to provide the best site experience.
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Настройки cookie / Manage cookies
Файлы cookie, необходимые для корректной работы сайта, всегда включены.
Остальные файлы cookie можно настроить.
Cookies necessary for the correct operation of the site are always enabled.
Other cookies are configurable.
Необходимые cookie / Essential cookies
Всегда включены. Эти файлы cookie необходимы для использования сайта и его функций. Их нельзя отключить. Они устанавливаются в ответ на ваши запросы, например, настройка параметров конфиденциальности, вход в систему или заполнение форм.
Always On. These cookies are essential so that you can use the website and use its functions. They cannot be turned off. They're set in response to requests made by you, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms.
Аналитические cookie / Analytics cookies
Disabled
Эти файлы cookie собирают информацию, которая помогает нам понять, как используются наши сайты или насколько эффективны наши маркетинговые кампании, а также помогают настроить сайты под вас. Список используемых аналитических файлов cookie можно посмотреть здесь.
These cookies collect information to help us understand how our Websites are being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customise our Websites for you. See a list of the analytics cookies we use here.

Flow in the Noise:
Levels of Engaged Activity

Deadlines are burning. The phone won't stop ringing. Two desks away, people are arguing. And you stay focused: you work tirelessly, lose track of time, and the work pays off.

The Zen master Hakuin wrote: "Meditation in the midst of activity is a thousand times superior to meditation in stillness." Working in silence is training. The real art is entering flow in the noise.

This article is about how such a flow comes together. I unpack the mechanics of flow using the chakra system as an example: it seemed to me the most detailed system I know. This is my working model of flow, and we use it in our project. Along the way I show where it agrees with researchers and where it parts ways.

What is flow

The classic description belongs to Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi; it was set out in detail together with him by Jeanne Nakamura. The conditions of flow: the challenge stretches your skills but does not exceed them; goals are clear and near; feedback arrives at once.

Its signs: absorbed concentration, a merging of action and awareness, the loss of reflective self-consciousness, a sense that you are coping, distorted time, and a feeling that the activity is valuable in itself.

Levels of engaged activity

The model works like this: flow rests on several levels (layers; it is the same thing). They do not form a strict sequence and switch on in different ways, but a missing level is felt. A few words on each.

Safety and responsibility

What can go wrong, and what do you do about it? A pilot, a surgeon, a builder, an architect: for them risk assessment does not come before the work; it is part of it. Without it, in a risky line of work flow turns into destruction.

That is also a condition of flow: the challenge must not exceed the skill. When it does, a person first becomes wary, then anxious, and flow does not start.

Entering the work through joy

Entering the work with joy, doing it with joy, and getting joy at the end. I have taught people to swim butterfly (technically the hardest stroke). Everything clicked when each movement, from entering the water to the stroke, began to be done with pleasure, and the body adjusted itself.

Ryan and Deci call this intrinsic motivation. By their account, the "I must" motivation, born of fear or guilt, comes with more anxiety. But they also note that even an unpleasant task can be done autonomously if a person sees the goal as their own. So my criterion is this: not "pleasant," but "chosen by oneself and without violence against oneself."

Will

Will is worth spending on external obstacles: deadlines, complexity, circumstances. Spending it on forcing yourself to begin is inefficient: the strength and attention the task needs go into an inner conflict.

The idea that willpower is depleted like a reserve was tested by Hagger and colleagues in a large preregistered study, and they found no effect; another large check found a small one. The idea is contested, so I speak not about a reserve but about direction: where the will goes.

Contact

Connection with people and with the work.

Empathy comes in two kinds. Cognitive: understanding what is happening to a person and what they want, without necessarily sharing their feelings; it helps choose the right next step.

Affective: feeling what they feel; it gives warmth and trust. Next to them stands compassion, the wish to help. And simple agreement, supporting any decision even when the next step is wrong, is no longer empathy but concession.

Expression

Thought takes form, inner or outer.

Inner: a programmer talks a task through in blocks, structures and classes before the first line of code; a writer sees a scene in images; a musician hears the melody before picking up the instrument; a painter assembles the picture in the mind; a swimmer above a reef builds an image from what they see.

Outer: an actor expresses a role, a reader brings a text to the hall, an orator builds a speech. What is not expressed does not move.

Navigation

Reliance on past experience: templates and behavior patterns that have already worked. This is structural navigation. When there are no templates, intuition switches on: a sense that comes before words. In me the first prevails: I first look for a proven template and compare the new task with it. In the description of flow, this layer corresponds to clear goals and feedback.

Meaning beyond oneself

Work in a team, work in a project that others need, benefit to people. There is work aimed only at oneself, without outer meaning. In my observation, it can produce flow, but sooner or later it runs dry: it has no continuation.

Outer meaning is also a support: you can lean on it when neither strength nor mood is there. Frankl wrote that a person is always directed toward something or someone beyond themselves, and that self-actualization is possible as a side effect of such self-transcendence.

In classical kundalini yoga, the summit of the path is union with the whole, dissolution. Closer to me is something else: meaning beyond oneself without dissolution, keeping oneself.

I have said what happens without safety and without meaning beyond oneself. About the other levels, think for yourself: which of them is slipping for you?

When the scheme works differently

This is a general scheme of engaged activity, and it describes best the risky kind: there, without safety, flow will not start.

But the order is not rigid. In work without risk, in creative work for example, safety may barely take part, and flow begins with joy or with expression. Some people enter flow through image and feeling rather than through structure: joy is enough for them, and then everything switches on by itself.

A missing layer does not always make flow impossible, but its absence is felt: flow holds worse and shorter. That is why I read the levels as a system, not as a ladder.

Two kinds of experience: flow and relaxation

Nakamura and Csikszentmihalyi allow, at the end of their chapter, two kinds of intrinsically rewarding experience. One is about expanding possibilities: this is flow, which we have been discussing above. The other is about conserving energy: this is relaxation. The authors call this a hypothesis, not a conclusion.

Winnicott, in his paper "The Capacity to Be Alone" (1958), writes that this capacity is one of the most important signs of emotional maturity and grows out of the experience of being alone in the presence of a reliable person. Relaxation, like flow, needs support. That is why safety is the first level for me.

On these two states we build our work. We provide the environment, the method and the accompaniment, and the choice is the person's.

The same process in the language of chakras

Here is the system I used as an example to unpack the mechanics of flow. It can be carried over to other systems. Muladhara: support and risk assessment. Svadhisthana: entering the work through joy. Manipura: will directed outward. Anahata: contact and empathy. Vishuddha: expression. Ajna: navigation, structural or intuitive. Sahasrara: meaning beyond oneself.

Schools describe the chakras differently: according to one overview, the Tibetan system has no analogue of the first chakra at all. So I prefer to explain through activity: in the process the chakras converge, while taken one by one they produce disagreements.

For me a chakra is a psychoenergetic zone of a person, including a stage of development. The chain of levels shows these zones in action, but the mechanics of flow do not depend on this language. This is close to Jung, who read the symbols of kundalini yoga as phases in the development of consciousness, and to Anodea Judith, the author of a well-known Western book on the chakras: for her each zone includes and rests on the one below it, and creativity belongs to expression, as in my model. But in a few places I understand the chakras differently.

Muladhara. For me it is inner support and independence, not money and not material survival. You can be penniless and strong in this zone, or a millionaire and weak: money is a tool. For Judith it is survival and material support. In psychology, related ideas are defined differently too: Ryan and Deci separate autonomy from independence. I do not set support against connection with people: according to Winnicott, it grows precisely out of connection.

Svadhisthana. Pleasure at the entrance, in the process and at the exit, not only the receiving of pleasure.

Sahasrara. In the classical tradition the summit of the path is union with the whole and dissolution. For me it is meaning beyond oneself without dissolution, keeping oneself. Closest to me are Frankl and, according to a review, Judith.

Epilogue. First grade

First grade. The bell rings, and the teacher still hasn't come; we barely know one another, and we sit not knowing what to do, whereas in an older class everyone would have run off long ago.

I get up from my seat, walk to the teacher's desk, the first one, in front of everyone, sit down at it and open The Wizard of the Emerald City. I read aloud, with expression, and nobody objects: everyone listens until the teacher arrives, closer to the end of the lesson, and only then do I realize how much time has passed.

This repeated for several school days that week: the bell, the teacher's desk, the open book, and after it, its sequels.

I did not yet know then that this is called flow, and what it is made of.

On how these ideas work in our project, more in the Manifesto.

Sources

  • Nakamura & Csikszentmihalyi, The Concept of Flow (2002): chapter text.
  • Ryan & Deci, Self-Determination Theory (2000): paper.
  • Winnicott, The Capacity to Be Alone (1958): text.
  • Frankl, self-transcendence, as presented by P. Wong: article.
  • Jung, The Psychology of Kundalini Yoga (1932): Princeton University Press edition.
  • Anodea Judith, Wheels of Life (1987): cited via a Lucid Body review.
  • Hakuin: the quotation is given in one translation; other editions give a different multiplier.
Message us:
© 2026 Expedition club Mir Vmeste: Dve Stihii | Privacy Policy